
If you are raising a child with dyslexia, you know what it looks like when they get something wrong.
The slumped shoulders. The jaw that tightens. The flash of frustration before they pull back behind whatever expression they’ve learned to wear when they don’t want anyone to see how hard this is.
And as a parent, your instinct is immediate and loving: fix it. Explain what went wrong. Show them what to do differently. Help them feel better by giving them a path forward.
What if that instinct, as natural and well-meaning as it is, is making your child’s fear of failure worse?
New research out of the University of Auckland suggests that is exactly what happens for many children. And for a child with dyslexia, who is already navigating one of the most mistake-dense learning environments of any child in their classroom, the implications are significant.
What Researchers Found When They Recorded Real Conversations
Researchers at the University of Auckland studied 231 mother-child pairs, recording real conversations about a recent setback or disappointment. Published in the British Journal of Educational Psychology, the findings were striking:
- 40% of mothers either minimized or didn’t acknowledge their child’s emotional response at all
- 55% never discussed any kind of collaborative action plan with their child
- 79% never discussed shared resources, things they could work on together
But the finding with the most direct implications for parents of dyslexic children was this:
| When mothers jumped straight to problem-solving, without first acknowledging their child’s emotion, children’s fear of making mistakes actually increased. Not decreased. Increased. |
Conversely, when mothers acknowledged their child’s feelings first, genuinely and specifically before offering any solutions, and then moved to collaborative problem-solving together, children’s fear of mistakes decreased significantly.
The order of those two things matters enormously.
Why This Matters More for Children with Dyslexia
For a typical child, mistakes are part of learning. But for a child with dyslexia, mistakes are not occasional events. They are the texture of every single school day.
Reading the same word wrong on line four that they read correctly on line one. Spelling a word incorrectly that they’ve practiced dozens of times. Forgetting a phonics rule that seemed solid last week. Getting called on in class and having every fear about their brain become visible to their peers.
Research from the International Dyslexia Association confirms what every dyslexia parent already knows: anxiety is the most frequent emotional symptom reported by both children and adults with dyslexia. The anticipation of possible failure when asked to read or spell can provoke anxiety that many teachers and parents misinterpret as laziness or avoidance.
It is not laziness. It is a nervous system that has learned to protect itself.
| “The anticipation of possible failure can provoke anxiety and fear. Anxiety causes human beings to avoid whatever frightens them. The child with dyslexia is no exception.” — International Dyslexia Association |
The Two Minutes That Shape Everything
Think about what typically happens at your homework table when your child gets something wrong. They miss a word, or they spell it wrong, and within seconds, most parents do one of the following:
- Immediately correct the mistake and show the right answer
- Encourage more effort: “Try again, you can do it”
- Explain the rule they should have applied
- Reassure: “It’s okay, you almost had it”
All of these responses come from love. And according to the University of Auckland research, all of them, when they come before emotional acknowledgment, may be quietly increasing your child’s fear of making mistakes.
Because what your child needs in that moment, before any correction or encouragement or explanation, is to feel that their experience has been seen. Not fixed. Seen.
What to Say Instead: A Framework from the Research
Step 1: Acknowledge the emotion first.
Before anything else, name what you see. Be specific. Not “It’s okay” because that minimizes the experience. Instead:
“That was really frustrating. I could see how hard you were trying.”
“Reading that felt really hard today. That makes sense.”
Step 2: Move to collaborative problem-solving, together.
Not “here’s what you should do” but “what do you think we could try together?”
“What part felt hardest? Let’s look at it together.”
“What would help you feel more ready to try that?”
Step 3: Remind them of the resources around them.
Simply naming that they are not alone matters enormously.
“We’re going to figure this out together.”
The Deeper Truth About Dyslexia and Mistakes
Your child’s fear of making mistakes is not a character flaw. It is the entirely rational response of a child whose brain has registered, over and over again, that trying in this specific domain results in failure, and that failure is public, visible, and interpreted by the people around them as a reflection of their intelligence or their effort.
They are afraid to fail because they have been failing in this specific way, consistently, in front of others, for a long time. And nobody has explained to them, in terms they can actually feel, that the failure is a neurological reality that can be changed, not a permanent truth about who they are.
| Every time you frame a mistake as their brain still building a pathway, you protect their identity. Every time you separate who they are from what they are still learning to do, you keep the ceiling off. — Dr. Rebecca Troy |
Reducing Fear Is Powerful. Rebuilding the Pathway Is What Changes Everything.
Changing the way you hold those moments will make a meaningful difference to your child’s emotional relationship with reading and learning.
But I want to be honest with you about something.
Reducing the fear of failure is not the same as eliminating the reason for it. Your child is making more mistakes than their peers because the neurological pathway responsible for connecting letters to sounds automatically, the pathway that makes reading feel effortless for a typical reader, is under-built.
Under-built. Not broken. Not permanent. Under-built. And under-built can be rebuilt.
When the reading pathway gets rebuilt, when decoding becomes automatic and effortless, the number of mistakes decreases. And when the number of mistakes decreases, the fear decreases with it. Not because we told your child to be less afraid. But because their brain gave them new evidence.
Across 129 of our 2025 program graduates, families saw an average of 42.5 percentile points of reading growth in 16 weeks. 88% of students reached the average range. Students who started below the 10th percentile climbed to the 46th.
Not because they became braver. Because their brain became more capable, and that capability changed the story.
Three Things You Can Do Starting Tonight
- Before you correct, acknowledge. The next time your child makes a reading mistake, pause. Name what you see before you fix it. “That one is tricky. I can see you were working hard on it.” Then, and only then, move to the correction.
- Replace ‘try harder’ with ‘your brain is still building this.’ This is neurologically accurate. The pathway is under construction. Telling your child that is the truth, and it removes the implication that effort alone is the variable.
- Protect their identity from the struggle. Your child is brilliant, creative, funny, and capable in ways that no reading test will ever measure. Say that. Often. Not as consolation, but as fact.
Ready to Go Beyond the Homework Table?
If you are a parent of a child with dyslexia who is tired of watching effort fail to produce the progress your child deserves, and you want to understand what is actually happening in their brain and what the neuroscience says actually changes it, I’d love to walk you through it.
Our free 45-minute Dyslexia Masterclass covers exactly this: the neurological reason the gap exists, why most interventions address the wrong thing, and what it looks like when a family finally targets the right one.
Watch the free masterclass: https://masterclass.retrainthedyslexicbrain.com/
Or join us at the next Dyslexia Discovery Workshop, a live 90-minute session where I walk you through the signs of dyslexia at every age from 4 to 17 and you leave knowing exactly what to do next.
Register here: https://www.retrainthedyslexicbrain.com/dyslexiadiscoveryworkshop
About the Author
Dr. Rebecca Troy, EdD is the founder of Retrain the Dyslexic Brain™. With 20 years in public education, a decade training reading specialists at the university level, and personal experience as the mother of two children with dyslexia, Dr. Troy developed the PTO Reconnect Protocol™, a neurologically grounded reading intervention program serving families across four continents. She is a TEDx speaker whose talk “The Dyslexic Brain: Rewiring for Reading and Unlocking Potential” has been viewed by families worldwide.
References
University of Auckland (2025). Mother-child conversations about setbacks and children’s fear of failure. British Journal of Educational Psychology.
International Dyslexia Association. Social and Emotional Problems Related to Dyslexia. dyslexiaida.org.
Mitchell, B. & Yeatman, J. (2025). Precision brain imaging and the Visual Word Form Area. Nature Communications.
Huber, E. et al. (2018). Rapid and widespread white matter plasticity during an intensive reading intervention. Nature Communications.
Troy, R. (2025). PTO Reconnect Protocol™ outcome data, 129 graduates. Submitted to the International Dyslexia Association. Unpublished.